Orlando Pirates’ Handling of Saleng Sparks Debate Over Player Welfare
A recent fly-on-the-wall documentary aired on SuperSport has raised questions about Orlando Pirates’ treatment of Monnapule Saleng. The footage sheds light on internal tensions and player welfare, especially regarding mental health struggles.
A Key Player in the Spotlight
Monnapule Saleng played a vital role for Orlando Pirates during the 2023/24 season. He was one of South Africa’s most promising footballers. However, the 2024/25 season saw him sidelined for much of the time. This led to speculation about his future at the club.
Reports suggest a standoff between Saleng and Pirates over his contract. The player felt his importance to the team should warrant a pay increase, similar to the club’s top earners. Alongside this, Saleng struggled with his mental health, adding further strain to the situation.
Documentary Exposes Tensions
The documentary, focusing on Pirates’ Carling Knockout Last 16 clash against Magesi FC, revealed some tense moments. At half-time, with Pirates trailing 3-0, head coach José Riveiro can be heard asking, “Do I have to do five subs? Is everybody alright? Saleng, are you alright?” When Saleng shook his head, Riveiro decided to substitute him, saying, “No? Okay, out. Where is [Mohau] Nkota? Take Nkota.”
Riveiro later described the situation, saying, “The period of decision was weird, with Saleng… He takes you to a weird space, to speculate if he’s okay or not, if he really wants to play for the team.”
Mental Health and Management Issues
Saleng spoke about the incident, acknowledging that many factors contributed to the situation. “What caused the situation? A lot of things. A lot of things happened,” he stated, hinting at deeper issues.
Many have questioned whether airing such personal moments was necessary. Exposing Saleng’s mental health struggles to the public has sparked debate. Some argue that it feels more like deflection from the club’s side, distancing themselves from the blame.
Club’s Image and Transparency
While Orlando Pirates might argue the documentary shows transparency, the decision to air such sensitive footage risks damaging the relationship between the team and its supporters. Showing Saleng’s struggles could have been handled with more care.
At a time when mental health awareness is crucial, the club might have protected its player better. Publicly sharing such vulnerable moments may undermine the trust between players and management.
Check also: Orlando Pirates Set for Tough Battle Against Mamelodi Sundowns
Saleng’s loan move to Orbit College could offer him the fresh start he needs. It may help him regain both his form and mental health. For Pirates, the next steps are critical in mending their relationship with Saleng and managing such issues more thoughtfully in the future.
The documentary raises an important question: how should South African football clubs balance transparency with protecting their players’ dignity and mental health?
What are your thoughts on Orlando Pirates airing such sensitive footage? Was it necessary, or should they have handled it differently? Let us know in the comments.
