The Pretoria High Court recently heard that Dr Nandipha Magudumana was compensated for the use of her archival material in the contested Netflix documentary about her and Thabo Bester. Despite this, Magudumana and Bester have sought a court interdict to block the release of Beauty and the Bester… A three-part true-crime series detailing Bester’s life and criminal activities.
Table of contents
Background of the Case
Thabo Bester, a convicted rapist and murderer, and Dr Nandipha Magudumana, his partner, are currently facing charges related to his dramatic escape from Mangaung prison. Where Bester was serving a life sentence. The Netflix documentary explores Bester’s crimes, alleged prison escape. The documentary also includes their lives while on the run before their capture in Tanzania in 2023.
Both have approached the court seeking an urgent interdict to prevent the documentary from airing. Their legal teams argue that the series prejudices their right to a fair trial and effectively convicts Bester in the court of public opinion before his ongoing trials conclude.
Payment for Archival Material
In court proceedings, it was revealed that Dr Magudumana signed an agreement with the production company. Storyscope is the production company behind the production the Netflix documentary. She was paid for the use of her archival material in the film. Magudumana’s legal representatives now contend that the contract is unenforceable, citing procedural flaws, including the alleged absence of authorization by the production company’s agent.
Netflix’s legal counsel, however, argued that Magudumana’s claims distort the contract’s contents. It was further stressed that she was represented by legal counsel when entering into the agreement, making the contract valid and binding.
Arguments in Court
Magudumana’s lawyer claimed the documentary has not given her proper opportunity to respond to issues raised about her role. Meanwhile, Bester’s legal team emphasized that screening the documentary would be prejudicial. Especially, since Bester has not been convicted of the charges related to his alleged escape and other accusations.
Conversely, Netflix’s officials maintained that the film provides victims of Bester a platform to share their stories… Highlighting the importance of public awareness and justice for victims. Netflix’s legal team also stressed that all facts presented have been previously reported in courts and the media, asserting there is nothing new or defamatory outside of public knowledge.
Court’s Pending Judgment and Release Schedule
On 11 September 2025, the Gauteng High Court reserved its judgment. The judgement was then scheduled to be delivered just 30 minutes before the documentary’s planned global release on Friday, 12 September 2025. The judge’s ruling would decide whether the documentary could be aired as scheduled or if its release should be postponed until ongoing legal processes are complete.
Proceedings on 12 September 2025
The Gauteng High Court in Pretoria dismissed the urgent application filed by Thabo Bester and Dr Nandipha Magudumana seeking to block the Netflix documentary “Beauty and the Bester” from airing. The ruling came just minutes before the documentary’s planned global release on 12 September 2025. The judge found the application to be “wholly unreasonable,” “without merit,” and noted that the urgency was self-created by the applicants.
The court emphasised that information about both individuals is already in the public domain and that other legal avenues, such as defamation lawsuits, are available if further redress is necessary.
Netflix’s legal team argued all content represents facts already public and that prior restraint on the documentary’s airing was unjustified. Magudumana was disclosed to have been paid for the use of her archival material in the documentary. Consequently, the documentary was permitted to be released as scheduled. This decision balances protecting individual rights with upholding freedom of expression and the public interest in high-profile cases.
Documentary Synopsis
Beauty and the Bester details several aspects of Bester’s criminal case, including his convictions for rape and murder, his escape from prison, and subsequent evasion of authorities with Magudumana’s alleged assistance. The documentary also explores the extensive police manhunt that ended with their arrest and deportation to South Africa.
This documentary follows years of public interest and media attention surrounding the “Facebook Rapist”. This is a moniker Bester earned for targeting victims via social media. The series intends to give victims a voice and reveal how such criminals operate behind closed doors.
CHECK OUT: End of SABC TV Licences: What You Need to Know
Beauty and the Bester
This ongoing legal battle encapsulates fundamental tensions between the rights of accused individuals to a fair trial and the public interest in transparency and victim restitution. The court’s imminent decision is highly anticipated as it balances these competing concerns within South Africa’s justice system.
The Netflix documentary stands as a significant cultural and legal event, demonstrating the power of media to influence public opinion. These events raise important questions about justice, privacy, and accountability in high-profile criminal cases.
