Warning: New Car Insurance Scam Using AI Puts South African Motorists at Risk

South African insurance companies are raising the alarm over a new wave of car insurance fraud that makes use of advanced artificial intelligence (AI) tools. Fraudsters are increasingly using AI to create fake images and forged documents for fraudulent vehicle claims. This has prompted insurers to take stricter measures in detecting and preventing these scams.

Ayanda Mdhluli, senior cybersecurity manager at Old Mutual Insure, revealed a sharp spike in AI-enabled scams. Perpetrators use digital tools to manipulate evidence and file bogus claims. One common tactic includes using AI to generate fake photos showing damage to a vehicle, such as a dented door. They then submit those images as proof of an accident that never occurred.

Insurers Strengthen Verification Measures

To counteract the surge in fraudulent activity, car insurance companies are enhancing their fraud detection strategies. Old Mutual and other providers have introduced their own AI systems. These systems verify the authenticity of images and documents submitted in claims. They are capable of identifying AI-generated visuals and flagging suspicious content.

Mdhluli explained that relying on photo evidence alone is no longer enough. Insurers now cross-reference claims with additional sources. These sources include eyewitness reports from emergency responders, tow truck operators, and other individuals present at the scene of an incident.

“We are actively using AI to improve our fraud detection and protect honest policyholders,” Mdhluli said. “When fraud is uncovered, we report it to the Insurance Crime Bureau to inform the wider industry.”

Consequences for Fraudulent Activity

Attempting to cheat the system doesn’t just lead to claim rejections—it could also have serious legal consequences. Fraudsters risk being blacklisted, losing their insurance cover, and facing criminal charges that could lead to jail time.

In addition to AI, companies are also relying on technologies like geo-tagging, biometrics, and digital forensics. These technologies help uncover inconsistencies in claim submissions.

Scams Becoming More Sophisticated

Despite generative AI still being relatively new, it’s already contributing to a noticeable rise in fraudulent claims. According to Old Mutual, scammers have reused the same AI-generated images across multiple claims. Additionally, they have downloaded photos from the internet to fabricate invoices.

In some cases, scammers have submitted repeated invoices from the same third-party service providers. These providers include repair shops or glass fitment centres. They have done this across different claims. One particular scam involved a staged crash. A car was deliberately damaged and taken to a panel beater. The investigation linked the incident to a larger crime ring operating across provinces.

Used-Car Market Also Affected

Fraud isn’t limited to car insurance claims. The second-hand vehicle market is also experiencing a rise in AI-assisted deception. Sellers are falsifying key documents and details about cars to mislead buyers.

Buyers are advised to request and verify the car’s NaTIS certificate to avoid falling victim to these schemes. This certificate confirms legal ownership. If a seller fails to produce the certificate or provides one that appears suspicious, it may indicate a forged document. Suspicious signs include typos or formatting errors.

Stay Alert, Stay Informed

As the technology behind scams becomes more convincing, both motorists and insurers must stay vigilant. Policyholders are urged to provide accurate information, verify documentation, and report any suspicious activity to authorities.

The fight against AI-powered fraud is ongoing. However, with enhanced detection systems and greater public awareness, insurance providers hope to keep one step ahead of scammers.