NHI Court Battles: Health Minister Justifies R10 Million Legal Bill
The South African Department of Health has spent nearly R10 million defending the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act and the National Health Act in court amid multiple legal challenges. Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi justified this expenditure, explaining that the department faces seven separate lawsuits related to the NHI and National Health Acts, necessitating a large legal team to manage the complex litigation.
ALSO READ: City Of Johannesburg Unveils R89 Billion Budget Plan for 2025/26 Financial Year
Legal Team and Costs
Motsoaledi revealed that since October 2023, the department has paid approximately R9.7 million to a legal team comprising five senior counsel and seven junior counsel. This team defends the government’s universal health policy and the NHI Act. The Act aims to provide all South Africans with equal access to quality healthcare funded through taxpayers. The minister emphasised that the high legal costs are due to defending multiple cases simultaneously.
Grounds for Legal Challenges
The legal challenges come from various stakeholders, including the Board of Healthcare Funders, the South African Private Practitioners Forum (SAPPF), the South African Medical Association (SAMA), and other private healthcare entities. These groups contest the constitutionality and implementation of the NHI Act. They cite concerns such as:
- Lack of clarity about which services will be covered by NHI
- Alleged infringement on constitutional rights, including discrimination against asylum seekers
- Restrictions on medical schemes and concerns over financial sustainability
- Vague provisions delegating excessive powers to the Minister of Health and the NHI Fund
The litigation includes five cases against the NHI Fund and two against the National Health Act.
Opposition Criticism and Department’s Response
Opposition parties have questioned the justification for the high legal spending amid ongoing healthcare funding challenges. Democratic Alliance MP Michéle Clarke highlighted the contrast between the Health Department’s large legal team and the limited resources for departmental responsibilities. These responsibilities include patient care, food and overtime pay for doctors. Motsoaledi responded by noting the substantial subsidies private medical aid members receive. These additional costs amount to billions of rands. Therefore, they contribute to the need for the NHI system, hence the resulting litigation.
CHECK OUT: Alexandra Residents Clash with City Power Over Illegal Electricity Disconnections
Additional Financial Burdens on the Healthcare System
Motsoaledi also pointed to medico-legal claims due to negligence and fraudulent activities as an additional financial strain on the health system. He stressed that fraud accounts for a large portion of these costs. Additionally, overworked healthcare workers sometimes contribute to unintentional errors.
The Contentious Nature of NHI Policy
The ongoing legal battles reflect the contentious nature of the NHI policy. President Ramaphosa signed the policy into law in May 2024. The High Court has ordered the president to disclose records related to his decision to assent to the NHI Bill. The ruling is currently under appeal. Ramaphosa has described the decision as politically sensitive. The president’s stance highlights the complex legal and political environment surrounding the NHI implementation.
The Health Department’s nearly R10 million legal bill stems from defending multiple high-stakes court cases challenging the NHI Act’s constitutionality and implementation. Minister Motsoaledi maintains that the size and cost of the legal team are appropriate given the volume and complexity of the litigation. These disputes underscore the broader tensions in South Africa’s healthcare system. The Health Department seeks to transition towards universal coverage while balancing the interests of private and public sectors.
