Healthcare Access for Undocumented Migrants in South Africa: What You Need to Know

Access to healthcare is a fundamental human right enshrined in South Africa’s Constitution. However, the reality for undocumented migrants seeking medical care in the country remains complex and often fraught with challenges. This article provides a clear, factual overview of healthcare access for undocumented migrants in South Africa. It highlights legal rights, barriers faced, and ongoing debates.

ALSO READ: Gauteng Hospitals Undergo Tech Overhaul to Speed Up Diagnostic Scans

Legal Framework Protecting Healthcare Access

Section 27(1) of the South African Constitution guarantees everyone the right to access healthcare services, including reproductive healthcare. This right extends to all individuals within the country’s borders, regardless of nationality or legal status. Specifically, Section 27(3) mandates that emergency medical treatment must not be denied to anyone. This underscoring the country’s commitment to human dignity and health rights.

The National Health Act further supports this by stating that primary healthcare services are available to all people, irrespective of immigration status. Refugees, asylum seekers (with or without permits), permanent residents, and even undocumented migrants are entitled to emergency healthcare services. However, at the very least.

Categories of Migrants and Their Healthcare Rights

• Refugees and Asylum Seekers: Recognised refugees and those awaiting status have the same rights to healthcare as South African citizens. This includes access to clinics, maternal and child healthcare, HIV and TB treatment, and mental health support.
• Permanent and Temporary Residents: These groups also have access to public healthcare. Temporary residents are often required to pay fees based on income.
• Undocumented Migrants: While lacking legal documentation, undocumented migrants retain the constitutional right to emergency medical care. Access to non-emergency services is more limited and often subject to administrative discretion, but denying emergency care is unlawful.

Barriers and Challenges in Practice

Despite clear legal protections, undocumented migrants frequently face obstacles when seeking healthcare:

• Medical Xenophobia: Many migrants report discrimination and refusal of services by healthcare providers. This is due to their foreign status or lack of documentation. This practice undermines public health and violates constitutional rights.
• Fear of Deportation: Undocumented migrants may avoid seeking care due to fears. They fear that healthcare providers will report them to immigration authorities, as required by the Immigration Act.
• Cost and Accessibility: Some migrants are charged fees or denied free services, despite legal provisions. Language barriers and lack of information further complicate access.
• Policy Conflicts: The National Health Insurance Bill and Immigration Act introduce conflicting requirements. These sometimes restrict undocumented migrants’ access to healthcare. This contrasts with constitutional guarantees.

RELEVANT ARTICLE: Over 8 000 SA Healthcare Jobs Lost After PEPFAR Cuts – More Layoffs Expected by September

Recent Developments and Legal Pushback

The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has condemned the denial of healthcare to undocumented migrants as unlawful and discriminatory. It emphasises that healthcare is a right, not a privilege based on documentation.

In 2023, the Gauteng High Court ruled that pregnant and lactating women, as well as children under six, must receive free healthcare services regardless of nationality or legal status. This landmark ruling reinforced the principle of non-discrimination in healthcare access.

However, political tensions exist. Parties like ActionSA have criticised the SAHRC’s stance, arguing that unrestricted access by undocumented migrants strains the public healthcare system. These debates continue to shape policy discussions.

What This Means for Undocumented Migrants

While South African law protects undocumented migrants’ rights to emergency healthcare, practical barriers often limit access to comprehensive services. Advocacy groups urge healthcare providers to uphold constitutional rights and reduce medical xenophobia. Authorities encourage migrants to seek care without fear, assuring them that the law prohibits denial of emergency treatment.

CHECK OUT: How to Access Free Health Services in South Africa

Access For All?

The South African Constitution guarantees healthcare access for undocumented migrants, especially in emergencies. Yet, challenges such as discrimination, fear, and conflicting policies persist. Continued legal advocacy, public education, and policy reform are essential. They are necessary to ensure that all individuals, regardless of documentation status, can access the healthcare they need.