Gauteng Wins Legal Battle Over Waste Tender: Justice and Services Prevail

The Gauteng Department of Health (GDoH) has achieved a significant legal victory in the ongoing dispute over a R526 million medical waste management tender. On 15 July 2025, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) ruled in favour of the department. The ruling overturned a previous High Court ruling that had invalidated the tender due to procedural issues.

RELEVANT ARTICLE: Medical Waste Contract Upheld: What It Means for Public Health in Gauteng

Background of the Tender Dispute

The dispute began in November 2023 when the Gauteng Department of Health awarded the medical waste management contract to Tshenolo Waste and Phuting Medical Waste Management. Buhle Waste (Pty) Ltd, which had previously held the contract, challenged the awarding process. They alleged irregularities and the improper extension of the tender’s validity. This challenge led to a Gauteng High Court decision in late 2023 declaring the tender invalid.

Supreme Court of Appeal Overturns High Court Decision

The department argued that the High Court had misinterpreted the law and granted remedies not requested by Buhle Waste, effectively exceeding its authority. The SCA agreed, concluding that the case was “not ripe for adjudication” at the time of the High Court ruling. Consequently, the Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed Buhle Waste’s application and upheld the appeal. They ruled in favour of the Gauteng Department of Health. The ruling was made with costs, and it reinforced the legality of the tender process followed by the department.

The Importance of the Ruling

This ruling is a key legal victory and ensures the uninterrupted removal and disposal of medical waste across healthcare facilities in Gauteng. Effective waste management is essential for public health, as disruptions in services could lead to hazardous, contaminated environments in hospitals and clinics. Furthermore, the ruling highlights the critical role of legal clarity in maintaining public health standards.

Department’s Commitment to Fairness and Service Delivery

Motalatale Modiba, a spokesperson for the Gauteng Department of Health, praised the ruling. He reaffirmed the department’s commitment to due process, fairness, and transparent governance. Despite facing scrutiny over procurement processes in recent years, the judgment strengthens the department’s reputation. Furthermore, it enhances their ability to deliver essential services efficiently.

Public and Industry Reaction

The ruling has generated mixed reactions. Healthcare workers and hospital administrators have welcomed the clarity and continuity it provides, ensuring that medical waste management operations proceed without interruption. However, some civil society groups have expressed concerns about the transparency and accountability of public tender processes. They underline the need for ongoing vigilance in ensuring fairness.

Broader Implications for Governance in Gauteng

While the legal resolution provides certainty for this specific contract, it also highlights the ongoing challenges around public procurement governance in Gauteng. Building trust and ensuring transparency in tender processes remains a top priority for the provincial government. Public confidence is crucial for the successful delivery of services. Therefore, the department must continue striving for improved accountability and fairness in procurement practices.

What This Means for Waste Management Services

With the tender upheld, Tshenolo Waste and Phuting Medical Waste Management can now proceed with their responsibilities. They will safely manage medical waste across the province. This contributes to maintaining hygiene and safety standards in healthcare facilities, reducing risks to both patients and healthcare workers.

The Contract and Its Scope

The contract, valued at R526 million, covers the collection, treatment, and disposal of healthcare risk waste from Gauteng’s medical institutions. It is a vital component of the province’s healthcare infrastructure. The contract ensures that hazardous waste is handled safely and in compliance with public health regulations.

Legal Procedures and Future Oversight

This case serves as a reminder of the complexities involved in public procurement law. The Gauteng Department of Health has committed to ongoing monitoring of the contract to ensure compliance with its terms. They aim to promote best practices in future procurement exercises.

Want to see how community-led transformations are bringing fresh life and health improvements to local clinics? From Painting Walls to Planting Gardens: Clinics in Gauteng Get a Makeover. Click to explore the full story and discover the impact of this green renovation initiative.

Batho Pele

The Gauteng Department of Health is now focused on ensuring the uninterrupted delivery of medical waste services. This allows it to concentrate on public health priorities without the distraction of legal uncertainties. The department’s commitment to legal and service delivery excellence will continue. This will drive its efforts to improve healthcare outcomes for the people of Gauteng.